propose
#cots hashtag for covering the BSG meeting
@nga_uk
Anthony Walker of BSG opening
#cots meeting - need for coordination
Target for meeting to find consensus for engagement and get to initial thoughts on requirements/solutions for connectivity
#digitalbritain
To keep the noise down I will be liveblogging the
#cots meeting to
http://bit.ly/12nDRK #digitalbritain
Need to make sure scale issues in community networks don't inhibit new development and encourage inclusiveness - needs to be a low cost and open approach. Provides choice and enables users and service provders to connect
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:17:16 PM
BSG has discussed the issue widely: three streams:
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:19:20 PM
1) Wholessale product set
2) Operational issues
3) Commercial and contractual issues
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:19:51 PM
Guiding principles to structure the work:
1) To promote inclusion
2) To minimise cost and complexity for service providers
3) Minimise geographic 'splits'
4) Agnostic about tech
5) Builds on ALA principles
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:22:10 PM
Need for discussion with key standards bodies and acknowledge need to build relationships with them.
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:24:50 PM
View from BIS - Peter Macdougal
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:27:15 PM
BISc says communities will form basis of many groups to get to NGAcc
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:28:23 PM
#cots 9 to 12 month process minimum
BIS says local communities will have access to the fund for NGA in
#digitalbritain - aiming for Sept announcements
#cots
Open Access is preferred vehicle for receipt of public funds says BIS in
#digitalbritain
Now Chinyelu Onwurah from Ofcom
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:33:20 PM
Need to make sure NGA products 'map' to existing product sets says Ofco
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:34:24 PM
#cots what is the final third? (unlikely to be covered by major players) Where/how do we draw the line?
#cots Ofcom not interested in setting standards. Best left to industry bodies.
Ofcom going through the various products - but focusing on physical layers
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:40:17 PM
Ofcom seems to want to occupy its own particular 'timebubble' where NGA products are chained to the doctrine of equivalence
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:44:02 PM
Q from the audience from Intel re wireless and its part in NGA
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:45:17 PM
A Walker says it's not an issue.
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:45:38 PM
BIS says 'we are technology neutral' and confuses by using the term mobile
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:47:06 PM
Now meeting talking about state aids
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:52:15 PM
Trent Holmes from Thales local requirements can create a local monopoly which may contravene State Aids - needs careful handling. And good training for all sides.
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:53:36 PM
Ofcom stays hiding behind Feb 2007 DTI/Ofcom 'guidance' on public sector schemes
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:56:22 PM
Ofcom says that may be the need for some kind of aggregation of local authorities and manage trade-off between level of engagement and need to make progress with right level of skills
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 1:59:40 PM
#cots Concern: 60
or so people here and others missing. already some disagreement. very diverse group. Is concencus possible???
#cots Seem unclear on starting point. Do we understand how these networks will be built and the potential lack of technical depth for some?
worth Reading up on Ofcom ALA work. seems that will be of of the main foundations
#cots
Now I'm on a panel and liveblogging. But my connection fell over
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:16:58 PM
#cots From IFNL: not for profit, industry-owned clearing house is preferred solution. agreement from this side!
IFNL's thinking actually quite close to what we are thinking of for INCA
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:17:24 PM
I'm speaking next. Peter Shearman is talking about issues of scale and cost for local NGA schemes.
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:19:20 PM
Engagement needs to be on a commercial basis says CPs - but how can that work on a national service provider business model.
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:20:39 PM
I did my bit and now it's Malcolm Taylor
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:28:35 PM
Malcolm Taylor says 'we've been here before and reflections on what's been said so far - is it a Big Me
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:29:32 PM
Reflection of cable industry and will it happen now? And what abut the duopoly? The issues of scale and the stress between Innovation and Standardisation. And the possibility of innovation being stifled by too close an approach to standards
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:31:22 PM
#cots Comparison of patchwork quilt to inception of cable industry. now just 1 big group (arguably)
One of the other panelists has noticed my tweets and has asked if there are questions on
#digitalbritain NGA and
#cots
Now discussion of interconnect regimes and whether clear products can be delivered.
by brian_condon at 7/29/2009 2:35:11 PM
suggestion we can reuse a lot of historical work done on interconnection. Not IMO. Needs to be much simpler.
#cots